Blogs & Opinion

Football over finance

City can stand up against player power, says Jeff

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 29th September 2011 view comments

It's always eventful covering the Champions League, but Tuesday night took it to a whole new level.

In any normal week Manchester United throwing away a two-goal lead and conceding three goals at home would have got all the headlines, but everyone's focus was on the blue half of Manchester and on one man in particular.

Tevez: player power gone too far

Tevez: player power gone too far

If I refused to do my job on a Saturday, as Carlos Tevez allegedly did against Bayern Munich, there would only be one outcome, I would be shown the door and pretty swiftly, too.

And although I'm not earning £250,000 a week (not quite anyway!) it would no doubt be a lot easier to get rid of me. The same goes in any walk of life; if you're not doing your job, you will get the sack.

Manchester City are one of the few clubs in the world, because of their financial backing, that could show that players don't hold all the cards.

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

We all know about his gripes with the club, but there are ways to go about it and his apology the next morning really didn't hold water with me. He said it was all a misunderstanding, but that was in contradiction to his comments immediately after the game when he said his head wasn't in the right place to come on.

I was in the studio with Graeme Souness, Mark Hughes and Dwight Yorke and although we didn't know what was going on initially, it was clear something major was happening.

Graeme was particularly passionate on the subject because I think he simply couldn't get his head around how somebody could be so selfish. Take away how much Tevez is getting paid because players got paid well, relatively speaking, in Graeme's day, too.

I think what he couldn't grasp was how he could let his team-mates down. In Graeme's day you were a tight-knit unit, all pulling in the same direction and you would go and put your body on the line for each other, for your mates.

But maybe the Argentine's actions are just indicative of today's game.


Players tend to hold all the power these days but Manchester City are one of the few clubs in the world, because of their financial backing, that could show that players don't hold all the cards. They can do that by taking the appropriate action - whether that be by sacking him or making him play in the reserves.

That said if he won't play for the first team what chance have you got of him playing in the reserves!

It's a real shame though because since he arrived in England, Carlos Tevez has given me fantastic pleasure and enjoyment. He's a terrific footballer and when he played he would never give anything but 100 per cent.

Up until Tuesday we thought that no matter what his issues were with the club you could rely on him on match day, and no matter how unhappy he was personally he would go on the pitch and give everything.

I think when he does leave the country now - which seems inevitable with what's happened - he will be remembered by the fans for all the wrong reasons and that is very sad.


What Tevez also did was take away any attention from Edin Dzeko, whose actions were hardly praiseworthy either.

He's come in on big money, he's had one-and-a-half good games and he walks off the pitch shaking his head when he gets substituted, having been totally ineffective throughout the game.

That sort of open dissent really undermines the manager and he was fortunate that Tevez took all the headlines.

The sideshow on the touchline also distracted us from what was a very good performance from Bayern, who really took control after the first 30 minutes when City looked the better side.

There's no doubt that City are in one of the toughest groups and it looks like they will have to go and beat Villarreal home and away if they are to qualify for the knockout stages. I think they're capable of doing that, because the Spaniards are a shadow of the team they used to be.


With all the drama of Tuesday night it's easy to forget that there were three other English teams involved in the Champions League this week.

Chelsea and Manchester United both came away with a point a piece from their games and while Arsenal came away with all three, I thought Arsene Wenger took a huge gamble when he decided to sit Robin van Persie and Aaron Ramsey on the bench against Olympiakos.

In the end it proved to be a calculated gamble because they ran out 2-1 winners, but I was hugely surprised all the same because had they lost to the Greeks, qualification for the next stage of the competition would have been incredibly difficult and that would have been a financial hammer blow to the club.

Olympiakos were neat and tidy and surprised a lot of people, including me, but they are far from one of the best teams in Europe and at times Arsenal were in danger of being overrun by them, so the gamble could easily have backfired.

It was however, Arsenal's third win on the spin so there is encouragement there, but there is still a lot to be concerned about as well, especially with the prospect of Tottenham and the North London derby next.

Sol Campbell was in the studio with us on Wednesday night and he believes if Tottenham can keep Emmanuel Adebayor motivated he will be a handful against any team, including his former employers.

He really has started the season well and the little and large combination with Jermain Defoe up front really looks a threat. A few players left Spurs this summer but Harry Redknapp has amassed a fantastic squad.

Luka Modric appears to have his mind on the game again and is playing at his best; Scott Parker has been every bit as good as we all knew he was; Ledley King is playing games again; and then you've got Gareth Bale who appears to have overcome all his niggling injuries and is really flying at the moment. He's definitely back to his best and I'm not sure if Arsenal will be able to cope with him.

If Spurs get an early goal I really do fear for Arsenal and I can see this turning into a very long afternoon for all their supporters.

Join Jeff and the gang for Soccer Saturday this weekend at 12pm on Sky Sports News HD, channel 405.

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Jeba Yasmin (Liverpool) (Liverpool fan) says...

Jeff I completely agree with you! You've hit the nail on the head with this one - its embarassing for a manager to have to deal with the touchline antics of players - particularly in such an important game, where 100% effort is vital. Even if a player is unhappy or having problems with their club, the best thing to do is to participate when asked and respect the manager, players and fans - not make the issue a media circus. I personally feel sorry for Mancini, as he is constantly dealing with alot of volatile players who cant seem to control their temper.

Posted 22:03 29th September 2011

Paudie O mahoney (Chelsea fan) says...

well said jeff

Posted 18:33 29th September 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Chelsea go three points clear

Chelsea will be top of the Premier League table on Christmas Day after beating Stoke 2-0 at the Britannia Stadium.

Neville: Duo are miles away

Liverpool and Arsenal can forget about winning trophies until they learn how to stop the opposition, says Gary Neville.

Jose: My team were perfect

Jose Mourinho says his Chelsea players were "amazing" after they beat Stoke 2-0 to go three points clear of Man City.

Carlisle seriously injured

Former PFA chairman Clarke Carlisle has suffered serious injuries after being hit by a lorry.

Hyypia quits as Brighton boss

Sami Hyypia has left Brighton after the club accepted his resignation as manager.


Premier League: Chelsea show the fighting spirit in their 2-0 win at Stoke that can take them to the title

Premier League: Chelsea show the fighting spirit in their 2-0 win at Stoke that can take them to the title

Adam Bate looks at how Chelsea showed in their 2-0 win at Stoke City on Monday Night Football that they have the toughness as well as the quality needed to win the Premier League title this season...

Liverpool 2-2 Arsenal: Five talking points from Anfield

Liverpool 2-2 Arsenal: Five talking points from Anfield

"It was a bizarre game and lots of unusual things happened." That was how Sky Sports pundit Alan Smith summed up Liverpool and Arsenal's thrilling 2-2 draw on Super Sunday.

Newcastle 0-1 Sunderland: Reshuffled defence stand firm for visitors at St James' Park

Newcastle 0-1 Sunderland: Reshuffled defence stand firm for visitors at St James' Park

Adam Johnson once again grabbed the headlines in the Tyne-Wear derby, finding the net at St James’ Park for the third season in a row to help Sunderland to a record fourth-straight victory over arch rivals Newcastle in the Premier League.