Blogs & Opinion

Foreign policy's fine

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 6th October 2011 view comments

England have dominated the back pages during this week's international break, however all the talk has been about Fabio Capello's successor, rather than qualification for Euro 2012.

Sven Goran-Eriksson sparked the debate by suggesting that Arsene Wenger would be the perfect man to take over, but it's clear not everyone would be happy with another foreign manager.

From my point of view the best man for the job should be employed, regardless of what nationality he is. What you don't want is a footballing mercenary coming in because as well as being one of the most prestigious jobs in world football it is also one of the highest paid.

Candidates: Redknapp and Wenger in the frame for England?

Candidates: Redknapp and Wenger in the frame for England?

Wenger may be French but he has spent the last 15 years working in this country and knows our game as well as anyone else, so he would be more than qualified to do it.

That's not to say there aren't English candidates out there. Harry Redknapp is, of course, a prime candidate and for me it has to be somebody of that calibre coming in to takeover.

If you look around the national teams across the world it tends to be the emerging nations that go out and try to find a big-name manager for kudos in the hope of developing their game. You don't often get established nations employing a manager from outside their own country.

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

If the FA do approach Harry then he will be left with a very tough decision whether or not to leave Tottenham and take the job, but I think he probably would.

It would be the pinnacle of his career and it would be an opportunity which I suspect that Harry, deep down, never thought would be afforded to him. People have always labelled him as a 'wheeler dealer' which irritates the hell out of him and I can understand why because he's not a wheeler dealer, he's a fantastic football manager.

And I know you probably won't find many people at Southampton agreeing, but he has done a brilliant job pretty much wherever he has been, be it with Bournemouth, Portsmouth or Tottenham.

He always gets the best out of players and I see no reason why that wouldn't apply with England as well. So I'd hope he would take it if he was given the chance and I'd hope he'd be a humongous success as well.


Either way a lot of thought must go into the next appointment and the FA are not the only ones who have been pondering the situation judging by Jamie Carragher's comments this week.

Jamie is very much in the 'English manager for England' camp and has gone as far as to say appointing a foreign manager is tantamount to cheating and I understand where he is coming from.

It's not something which you can outlaw and I don't think it should be, but if you look around the national teams across the world it tends to be the emerging nations that go out and try to find a big-name manager for kudos in the hope of developing their game.

You don't often get established nations employing a manager from outside their own country, so I think he makes a fair point.

The Premier League is not littered with English managers, but there are enough candidates out there. Of course, we would love to see more British managers managing in the Premier League, but as much as we want it we can't have it if the owners want to make overseas appointments.

There's also been a couple of occasions where British managers have been given a chance and fans of these clubs have thrown their hands up in horror. Steve Kean at Blackburn is a classic example, while Newcastle fans weren't particularly happy with the appointment of Alan Pardew initially, yet he has done a brilliant job.

And with the Pardews, Tony Pulis's and Neil Warnocks of this world there is a decent sprinkling there. Of course, not all of them are England manager material, but I have to say I would love to see Neil Warnock in charge one day!

I think he would only last about a day, but it would be very entertaining to say the least!


Joking aside all of this will, of course, be hanging over the players' heads and I don't quite understand why there was a need for Capello to announce that he would be leaving after Euro 2012 - it puts everyone in a very unusual situation.

In my opinion he should have left immediately after the last World Cup. I don't think he's a bad manager and in fact on the couple of occasions I've met him I've found him a charming individual not in keeping with his sergeant major reputation with the players.

But after the debacle in South Africa I think he should have stood down like so many other managers, which would have avoided the situation we are in now.

Instead we would have headed to Poland and Ukraine - theoretically at least - with an established manager who could then take us onto the next World Cup finals in Brazil.

It's always difficult to part ways with managers when they are on the kind of money Capello is on, because you will invariably have to pay off the rest of their contract., but I think the FA were a bit weak in dealing with the situation.

Then again - and there's a way to go - if England go on to win the European Championships they will turn around and say it was money well spent.

Join Jeff and the gang for Soccer Saturday this weekend at 2pm on Sky Sports News HD, channel 405.

Comments (3)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Chris H (Torquay United fan) says...

Let's put it this way - the best candidate who happens to be foreign or the best English candidate who is about 10th best - no contest really.

Posted 11:13 7th October 2011

Jack Rogerson (Blackburn Rovers fan) says...

Hang on a minute, i'm sorry to go off topic but I have to ask "Steve Kean at Blackburn is a classic example"? Is Jeff Stelling seriously suggesting that when the Blackburn fans are allegedly throwing their hands up in horror, this is not justified and understandable? I completely agree with his stance on Alan Pardew and the terrific job he's doing at Newcastle... he shouldn't be getting the stick he does for doing such a fine job at the toon but that's geordie fans for you. However, When your club is sitting 19th and your manager is saying how well you played after a 4-0 defeat something's gotta give Jeff. British or not Mr Kean should be long gone and I feel so sorry for the Blackburn fans as their wonderful little club (no offence intended but let's face it, it is a small town lol) is being ruined before their very eyes and the majority of the national media persistently berates them for heckling Kean when I feel they are truly justified in doing so (whether he's British or not)!

Posted 00:26 7th October 2011

Joseph Grace (Manchester United fan) says...

we have had players not born in england playing for the national team for donkeys years.nobody said a word,but moan about a foreign manager.can't make it out!

Posted 17:40 6th October 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Paul Merson

Merson's predictions

Villa to beat Spurs and a draw in the Manchester derby... read what Paul Merson predicts this week....

Latest News RSS feeds

Sky Sports Today

Build-up to a busy weekend of football plus Norwich v Bolton updates

Van Gaal: Rooney will play

Louis van Gaal has confirmed Wayne Rooney will play and will captain Manchester United in Sunday's derby against City.

Premier League preview

The Manchester derby takes centre stage on Sunday, with form sides Chelsea, Southampton and West Ham playing Saturday.

Super 6: Tigers can halt Saints

Merse and Thommo backing a 1-1 draw at the KC Stadium

Hughes unhappy with FA

Stoke boss Mark Hughes feels the FA may have set a dangerous precedent by not charging Garry Monk over his 'cheat' slur.


What next for Spurs?

What next for Spurs?

"Lads, it's Tottenham."

Super 6 predictions: Pundits tip Tigers to halt Saints

Super 6 predictions: Pundits tip Tigers to halt Saints

Soccer Saturday pundits Phil Thompson and Paul Merson think Hull City could halt Southampton's Premier League charge on Saturday.

Gerrard and Ramsey figure on out-of-sorts list

Gerrard and Ramsey figure on out-of-sorts list

Sometimes the pressure of repeating an impressive season can prove hard to handle for players. It's not uncommon that the standards laid down one year are struggled to be met thereafter.